Search This Blog

Showing posts with label 9/11. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 9/11. Show all posts

Sunday, September 11, 2011

never say never


I've been wondering all week what to write.  A political rant?  A philosophical discussion starter? It would be easy to succomb to anger.  To criticize that we are more isolationist, less knowledgeable about the world around us.  That we are as likely if not more so now to turn our backs on the humanity of our fellow citizens.
But today can't be overtaken by anger. 
I have said many times that I want this blog to not only document our little urbansuburban existence, but to be something Mathilda will read someday to get a glimpse of how things were.  So, I decided to just write what happened, as I remember it.  I found the photos that I took that day, and some from Reggie, buried in a bin deep in the closet of my childhood bedroom. I don't think I've looked at them in 10 years. I've definitely never shared them.

I won't say never forget.  I don't have to.  I remember so well.
I lived on Union Square West at 15th St.
It was a Tuesday and I had an Anatomy and Physiology course that morning. The first plane crashed.  I thought it was a glitch. An air traffic control error.  Then the 2nd plane hit.  I went to the street.  I can't believe that I thought to bring my camera.  I wasn't scared.  I was confused.  I had no idea what to do.  There wasn't a script, no protocol to follow.


looking south. Im not sure what street I am on here, but I think Broadway, right by my apartment

again, south from our block

Incredibly, I went to class. We were dismissed after about an hour.  An entire hour.  Not learning.  Wondering what was going on outside.  Not knowing what to do.  When the crowds began rushing past the classroom window, our professor couldn't keep up the facade of normalcy, and told us to leave.  I walked northward towards my building with hundreds covered in soot and ash.  I searched the southern Manhattan sky for the towers but saw only smoke. I zig-zagged the blocks, trying to figure out why I couldn't see the buildings.  It hadn't occurred to me that they could fall.  I didn't realize the ash was the building.  The ash was desktop computers, toilet paper, elevator controls, coffee cups.  The ash was people.  In the days that followed we had to keep our windows shut, or the ash would cover our beds and desks.  We had to wear scarves over our faces in the street so we wouldn't breathe it in.
my corner

after the fall (I must have put black and white film in my 35mm 200 speed camera when the color ran out?).
9/12. View from Washington Square Park.


I passed a girl on the street. Probably a student. She had long dark hair.  She sat screaming on the curb.  Her father was in those buildings.  Strangers tried to soothe her, brushed her hair back as she cried.
Cell phones stopped working.  Lines formed at pay phones.  My mom couldn't get through to me.

I went to NYU's Coles gym with my dear friend and roommate, Bridgette, our backpacks full of bottled water and granola bars.  It was to be a triage center.  I think I might have also packed bandaids and neosporin.  Maybe they would be needed.  But no one arrived.  We left the supplies.  We heard there was a blood drive at St. Vincent's hospital.  The roads were closed- to keep them clear for the ambulances which would be bringing the injured any moment.  The subways also were not running.  So we ran to the hospital.  I handed out water with the MTA police.  The blocks were full of people in lines.  Type A, AB, O positive, negative.  We organized.  Because surely blood would be needed.

blood drive lines at St. Vincent's

St. Vincent Hospital

The National Guard and NYPD set up on our street.  We had to show ID to leave our block.
NYPD barricade at 14th St.

My new Resident Advisor, Reggie LaFond, was posted at the entrance to our building. Counting residents, assigning rooms for those displaced from the dorms located only steps from the World Trade Center.

I heard that a plane went down in Pittsburgh, and suddenly I was terrified.  I knew that I was ok, but hearing that my home town had possibly been attacked and I couldn't get through was too much to handle.  I learned soon about flight 93 and the field in Shanksville, PA.

A kid from across the hall, whose name I now can't even remember, a theater major, gay, skinny, with dark hair, shared my bed with me that week, not wanting to be alone.  People slept on our floor, unable to get back to their own rooms.  We watched Sex and the City DVDs. I made tuna noodle casserole.

That night, the discussions began.  I remember that I had heard that as far back as the civil war, people would gather in Union Square park to debate.  I stayed up very late in the park.  I remember starting to feel a part of something very very big.  I remember thinking, my children will ask me about this moment.
crowds gather in Union Square Park to debate the attacks and the appropriate response

By nightfall, makeshift memorials had been erected.  They would be elaborated on for weeks.  Posters searching for loved ones.  Signs decrying Al Qaeda, our government, too.  Us and them.   I remember thinking- who would attack us?  I mean, we have The Bomb, surely any country would be asking for certain decimation for attacking us!  And then, as war with other nations, or "terror" became imminent, I knew that no other 19 year old girl should have to experience what I had experienced that day.  Sadly, I know that for many 19 year old girls, 9/11 is an all too frequent occurrence. 






Re-telling the story, there are things we will always say.  "It was a day not unlike today," for example. Which is true most years.  A sunny warm day after a cool almost-Autumn night.  And of course, we say, always remember.  never forget.
But I will never say never forget.  I won't buy a t-shirt, a bumper sticker, a flag pin.  I won't post dramatic images of the towers or the pentagon on facebook.   The memory is too strong for a poster, a t-shirt, a slogan.  I cried today for the kids who won't know their parents, for the spouses, for the people on those planes and the sheer terror they must have felt.  We were all New Yorkers that day.
I'm glad the 10th anniversary has almost passed, and I'm sure I'm not alone.  It's a heavy memory but one that deserves to be told frequently and with feeling.  I hope I never forget that.

Thursday, January 14, 2010

the kindness of strangers

Is something that always takes my breath away. This post has been floating in my head for a week, but until this morning was too heavy to write.

9 years ago, I was a 19 year old, insecure, curious college student, drying my hair in the bathroom when my roommate yelled for me to look at the alert broadcast interrupting our usual routine of watching Good Morning America as we got ready for class. We watched as an airplane, smoke, and a small fire protruded from an upper floor of one of the twin towers. We speculated as to what could have gone wrong- air traffic control problem, we assumed. We finished getting ready, and walked out the door to our Union Square neighborhood, where we were met by what I recall to be dozens of people, not moving at the brisk new york morning pace we were used to, but standing still, silent, eyes fixed on the near horizon. From our front door we had a near perfect, unblocked view of the twin towers. In learning my way around new york city, I used landmarks as my compass. The twin towers my unwavering view of the south, the empire state building as my north star (in those early days, my new york world rarely extended above 34th st, so these landmarks sufficed).

It's funny because I don't remember if I saw the second plane hit on TV or live, if at all. There are moments of that day and the days that followed that are so real and raw it might have happened yesterday. But that is a detail I can't recall. For some reason, I had grabbed my camera. I have photos of faces familiar to me from living in the same dorm, walking the same path to class, staring at the sky.

And then I walked to class. I didn't know what to do. I had a 915am anatomy & physiology class in a classroom next door to the Village Voice office building. The streets were packed now. I heard someone say that people were jumping out of the windows of the towers. I took the long way to class, waiting to turn east until I came upon Washington Square Park. I dont remember if I saw this live- but I have an image of it in my head. From TV? It's interesting how the brain can make it's own memories, tricking us. The class was on the first floor, with large street-front windows. I sat in the back (some things never change), right by the windows. I remember suddenly what seemed like hundreds of people were running past the windows, covered in dust and white dirt. The professor, who had actually been trying to lecture, gave up and dismissed us. I went outside and joined the masses. The air was dusty, and frantic. I looked for my southern landmark to see if another plane had hit, or if the fire I had seen before was raging with more intensity. I couldn't find them. I ran with the crowd, crossing over to Astor place. Still couldn't see the towers. I don't remember how I learned that they had fallen. Did someone tell me? I crossed towards Washington Square Park. There were lines at the phone booths as most cell phone service was already disrupted (mine lasted another few hours- thank you Verizon, I will never leave you). A girl sat on the sidewalk, she was about my age, crying. Her dad worked in the towers.

I ran back to my building in Union Square. My Resident Advisor who I had met only a week before, and who I thought was cute, was directing traffic, giving information in the lobby. I met up with my roommate who told me a temporary hospital was being set up in the NYU gym downtown. We stuffed our backpacks with supplies (crunchy granola bars, water, and band-aids. Im not kidding. thats what I took) and ran back downtown. We got to the gym, and no one was there. No injured. We dropped off the supplies and learned that St. Vincent's hospital was having a blood drive. Blood would be needed for the survivors. We ran north. By this time the roads were closed to all traffic except emergency vehicles. I remember waiting for the hundreds of ambulances that surely would be taking the hundreds of injured people to the city's open hospitals. The lines to give blood were enormous. Money was being collected. The port-authority was handing out water to those in line. It was hot that day- now probably close to 11am, maybe noon. A combination of tattoos, foreign travel and low blood pressure kept me from the blood-giving lines, divided now by type, and I joined the people handing out supplies to the volunteers. I was overwhelmed by the people, just regular new yorkers, willing to do whatever they could to help. The people. Taking in the now homeless, lost, scared. People willing to do anything to help. Vigils were set up in union square. Hymns were sung, debates on appropriate retaliation raged. By now we knew it was a terrorist attack. Photos of the missing littered any immovable structure- subway walls, telephone poles, storefront windows, trees. Have you seen me?


9 years later, I am a slightly less insecure, slightly more curious, 28 year old graduate student. Starting a new semester, the first day of class. I am married to that resident advisor. I don't remember how we learned about the earthquake in Haiti. NPR? Did someone call? I was calm at first. Used to the over-sensationalization of the cable news. Im sure it's not that bad, we said. I posted to facebook- 7.3 quake hits port-au-prince. We waited. By the time we went to sleep, we knew. Something had happened, this was real. By the morning, the scene was worse. The photos of the missing covering the internet, cnn, facebook. Have you seen me? The cell lines were down, electricity was out. Reggie's grandmothers and great-grandmother still missing. His father's mother, an aunt and an uncle live outside of port-au-prince, we learned soon that they were safe. We watched in horror as the disaster relief didn't come. Where was the government? The bottled water? The blood drives? We watched as the true kindness of strangers became evident. People using their hands, basic household tools, blow-torches, shovels, hammers, dug through precarious rubble, listening for the sounds of the living buried below. All multi-story structures have fallen, we heard. We feared the worst. By Wed evening, the UN had mobilized and soldiers joined the Haitian people. Still no word from his family. What could we do? We texted to the red-cross, donating $10 at a time. Feeling that it wasn't enough. Calls to Reggie's mother and aunts only made us feel more panicked. What could we do? It killed us to sit on our hands, with only Anderson Cooper to show us what was left of the community that had been Reggie's childhood home, and the home of his parents, siblings, cousins.

We spent the winter holidays this year with Reggie's family, both in New York and Miami. We had been planning for a year to visit his grandmothers in Haiti over my Spring break- March 7-14. After being around my lovely Haitian family, I was more than excited to finally go. Making Reg have "creole-only" conversations with me, labeling household items, thinking of travel costumes to pack! I had finally convinced Reggie to take me after 5 years of pushing. What if they were dead? I never said it out loud. I kept thinking it, over and over. What would we do? What would his mother, his aunts? His grandmother is in her 70s, great-grandmother near 90. What if we never heard? How long do you wait? When could we go? We can go today! tomorrow! We will search! Other people's family members handed Anderson Cooper photos to show on TV- this person is deceased, this one is alive. we are ok! Photos were posted on facebook. Not unlike those crowded subway walls 9 years ago in new york. We waited. Then Thursday, early afternoon, we heard- They are alive!!! His grandmother and great-grandmother were alive! And uninjured! Their house was destroyed, but they were alive- and, from what I have been told, in typical Fils-Aime/Brutus women fashion- were in no rush to leave the country. His grandmother was cooking whatever food she had outside of what was left of her home, to help the volunteers. They were sleeping in the courtyard. These women AMAZE me! It would take an entirely new blog post to describe the resiliency of the Haitian people, most specifically the matriarchs in Reggie's family.

Of course, a consolidated, rapid government response to a crisis is absolutely necessary. We need police, fire, rescue, food, water, shelter. But it is the response of the ordinary person that really makes the difference. People didn't run, didn't flee to safer grounds. They stayed to help their neighbors. No food, no water, constant after-shocks. And people stayed. Reggie's grandmothers stayed! It was discussed in a family conference call yesterday that they will have to be CONVINCED to leave! All around the story is the same- people risking their own lives for the lives and security of others. millions raised through text-message donations. goods collected, waiting for the aid flights to be cleared. But more than what we do here, watching through the generator-powered lens of the cable news channels I so often eschew, the people of Haiti working tirelessly for each other, as history has time and time again forced them to do.

I will keep updating this blog with reports of Reggie's family. Our friends and family have also amazed us with their concern and generosity. Through hundreds of emails, phone calls, facebook posts, we have heard nothing but love and support from those around us. Thank you all so much. As of this morning, the plan is to get his fragile great-grandmother, Maurianne, (of course the term fragile takes on new meaning here!) to the airport. Her documents have to be located, but she is a US citizen, and we hope we will be able to get her to Miami within the week. His grandmother, Therese, will need to be convinced to leave, but we hope she is here safely soon.
Reggie and I still plan to go to Haiti in March. Sadly, it will not be the trip we had hoped for- full of catching up, sitting in the sun, visiting with cousins and relatives we see far too infrequently. A house is just a physical structure, of course.

I know in the coming months I will continue to be amazed by the awesome power of the kindness of strangers. I don't know if I believe in God, heaven, or hell, but it is nearly impossible to not be in complete awe of, and have faith in, the human spirit.

to follow information on the family, please check out the family facbeook group.

Jean-Yves & Reggie, in Haiti, ~ 1984.